Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Byron Allen Black's avatar

Before I even began to read your litany of [justified] misery, it occurred to me that uttering a “Why?” is one of the most subversive, dangerous moves one can make in a totalitarian matrix, whether it be family, church, team or state.

“Because I said so!” SMACK.

While the work of Solzhenitsyn comes to mind, I cannot relate a specific episode from his graphic, if horrifying, odyssey. Nevertheless, an inappropriate “Why?” was, as I recall (could be wrong) what adjusted his outlook in the direction of the gulag.

Once in the gulag there is certainly no space for any “Why?”

A “Why?” can also disastrously derail sunk cost momentum: you obey the order of a senior officer in the military, even while aware that such obedience can result in injury or death. Or you choose to face the consequences.

Such is the price we pay for membership in society, and often why we “barnyard animals” shut up and go along with despicable orders.

Lana the Free and Homer the Brave shine their shit-eating grin at us as they load up their SUV and head for the hills, contemptuous smart-asses so sure of themselves and their mighty land-o’-plenty.

Expand full comment
Geoffrey Newton's avatar

Its difficult to get a man to understand something that his salary requires him not to understand. Upton Sinclair

Expand full comment
34 more comments...

No posts